Who Owns the Track? Jagged Edge vs Ciara!

March 16, 2007 by GOT Staff

Who Owns the Track? Jagged Edge vs Ciara!

Welcome to the second edition of ‘Who Owns the Track?’ Where old school meets new! This one is a little tougher, I decided to go on and post it since both songs are similar in a way, our artists are Jagged Edge and Ciara; Jagged Edge with there hit “Promise” reaching #1 on the R&B charts and #9 on the Hot 100 and Ciara with hers debuting on the Billboard Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles at twenty-four. After two weeks on the chart, “Promise” debuted at #45 on the Billboard Hot 100, making the single Ciara’s highest debut and the top debut of that week (source: Wikipedia). There is this case – of course Jagged Edge would win because that was an ultimate hit, you can’t beat out the old school BUT Ciara has been on her grind lately, they play her single heavy down here, people seem to dig it so I think this would be a tie in my book because they both did their thing! Which version of “Promise” do you guys like?

Jagged Edge » “Promise” (Male Version) » Listen » (Full)
Ciara » “Promise” (Female Version) » Listen » (Full)

Filed: Who Owns the Track?

Links from Our Partners In Crime

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Melloney

    Hey wuddup,
    I think the song of Jagged Edge has more feelin, I feel that one more,
    But I feel the song of ciara 2 & it makes me dance on a slowjam.
    if I really have 2 pick one. I choose Jagged Edge because I think,
    I kinda feel that they sing wit their hearts.
    Peace

  • Miss O

    Definatly J.E.’s track! I so so loved that one back in the days..and I agree with Melloney^ They sing with their hearts..(like always!) Still I also really like Ciara’s song.. anda again agree with melloney.. it makes you dance.. I love the beat in it too..this was a hard one to decide cause I love them both.. but J.E. is a classis!! so..:)

  • http://www.passion-4-fashion.net Koriee

    Isnt this suppose to be the same song, cuase they are totally diffrent lol. I say Ciara anyway.

  • http://THINK2WICE.ORG Mike

    Yeah, I completely agree with Melloney, I think I like the J.E. “Promise” a little better. And Koriee, yeah they’re different songs but they are both similar in a way, that’s why I decided to post. They don’t necessarily have to be the exact same track, I said that in the first ‘Hot or Flop’ feature.

  • http://chrisbrownweb.com MostHated

    Ciara, for sure. Jagged Edge annoys the fuck out of me.

  • jon

    MOST DEF J.E…. they still in my ipod with this song after how many yearz? Will ciara do the same?? i doubt it…

  • http://xloveformusic.blogspot.com/ Quyen

    I think I’ll go with Jagged Edge.. but mainly cuz I find Ciara’s Promise annoying and boring!

  • Lea

    The only thing similar between the two songs is the mother effing title. Nothing is similar about the 2 songs moke. I’ll go with ciara’s promise. but jagged edge’s song is cool too, but all their slow songs sound the same…….no variation what so ever.

  • http://THINK2WICE.ORG Mike

    Lea… by “similar” I mean the concept, it’s just basically a male version and a female version to me, If you look up the lyrics to both you will see ;)

  • http://drakeonline.net K-Fresh

    CIARA, OF COURSE IS MY FAVORITE FEMALE ARTIST, BUT I HAVE TO GIVE IT TO JE. THEY KILLED THIS TRACK, AND THEY GOT THAT ONE

  • Judy

    Ciara`s, most def. =]

  • http://www.juicy-flawless.org flo

    Jagged Edge, easy.

    Ciara sucks. I don’t see the hype about her. If Baby Girl Aaliyah was still here, Ciara would be a joke. More than a joke she is now, I mean.

  • TERRELL

    FLO U NEED TO SHUT DOWN YO COMPUTER FOR WHAT U JUST SAID…YOUSE A STR8 HATA BRO…I RATHER TO LISTEN TO CIARA’S ‘PROMISE’ ANYDAY.

    AND U STUPID FOR WHAT YOU SAID. CIARA = JOKE….NEVER!!!!! THROW AWAY YO OLD ASS COMPUTER WITH DAT ONE!!!!!!!!!!

ADVERTISEMENTS